• August 2010

Alice Waagen talks about the rise and fall of Total Quality Management

By Dr. Alice Waagen
Founder and President
Workforce Learning

The 1990’s love affair with Total Quality Management (TQM) empowered work teams, process improvement, and other business buzzwords killed the professional manager.

Organizations flattened themselves, removing layers of managers, while distributing their responsibilities to key individual contributors.

This new breed of manager retained its full individual contributor duties while picking up the job of overseeing the work of staff. This concept of “working managers” permeates organizations today and has resulted, in my humble opinion, in a poorly run, overly stressed mess.

Nearly two decades later, we are still reaping the fruits of this flawed logic.

In most organizations, managers have a full plate of their own work to produce, while overseeing the work and assignments of staff.

And how does this really work? It is quite simple: The performance plans which guide a manager’s personal allocation of time and attention are chock full of his or her individual goals with scant mention of the management responsibilities.

These responsibilities, such as coaching, motivating, and assessing staff, simply drop off the plate. The manager’s function has shrunken to little more than occasional ad hoc conversations supplemented with a myriad of poorly written emails and a very painful event called the year end appraisal. (More on performance appraisals in the June issue of Be Inkandescent Magazine.

But here is the irony of it all.

Organizations have achieved little true cost savings by killing the middle manager.

Why? The work being done by the professional manager has not gone away. People still need direction and correction to successfully complete work assignments. Without this guidance, work is completed with errors and needs rework.

In my scan of organizations, I see lots of people working hard and putting in long hours. But the efficiency of this work is abysmal. My colleagues in Human Resources mostly pick up the slack when managers fail to manage. HR folks spend endless hours mediating disputes, coaching performance short falls, and calming down irate employees who clearly don’t know what’s expected of them.

What’s the result?

Managers aren’t managing, HR serves as de facto managers, and what happens to the HR work?

It gets delayed, causing more employee problems. It is enough to give anyone a headache.

I strongly encourage organizational leaders to rethink the concept of the flat organization and reinstate the profession of management.

Here are some simple steps that can push organizations closer to a better balance of management and work:

  • First, take a handful of your best and brightest managers and, over time, reduce their individual contributor goals to 50% or less of their current workload. At the same time, increase their number of direct reports by one or two positions to handle their individual assignments.
  • Second, augment managers’ individual performance plans with solid and detailed performance objectives that recognize and reward fundamental management skills. People are conditioned to focus on the goals in the plan. If there is no goal around management practices, time and attention will be focused on work goals.
  • Third, provide managers with many opportunities to develop and enrich their skills as managers. Since they’ve never been held accountable for truly managing, they probably do not know the fundamentals of how to allocate work, provide feedback, coach and correct.

I vote that we revive the long dead professional manager and use this valuable resource to create workplaces that are effective and efficient, as well as healthier and happier places to work.


About Alice Waagen

Alice Waagen, Ph.D., is president and founder of Workforce Learning LLC, a leadership development company she founded in 1997. In the past three years alone, more than 125 leaders from 24 different organizations have graduated from Alice’s unique leadership-development workshop series.

Previously, Alice served as senior director of corporate training for Amtrak in Washington, DC, and director of education, training and development for Freddie Mac in McLean, VA. In both of those positions, Alice created and implemented workplace development programs that served clients from the shop floor to the executive suite.

For more information, contact Alice at alice@workforcelearning.com

http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/2201/can-lsd-and-ecstasy-help-us-harness-the-power-to-heal http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/736/the+four+generations http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/323/the-magic-of-blackboard-inc http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/1924/michael-franti http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/2041/PR+Rules http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/1007/the-science-of-healing http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/974/dont+sweat http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/401/robert-s-rules-for-non-profits-businesses-volunteers-and-donors http://www.sharonarmstrongandassociates.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/690/good-ideas-optimism-and-a-healthy-splash-of-doing-good-success http://www.beinkandescent.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/1081/Pamela+Hartigan http://www.inkandescentnetworking.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/236/nell-merlino-s-tips-for-entrepreneurs http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/183/ted-leonsis-tips-for-entrepreneurs http://www.crewscontrol.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/articles/?c=hiring http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1849/Charting+the+Course http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/461/business-tips-from-the-love-doctor http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1702/marketing-professor-raj-sisodia-on-the-future-of-business-success http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/2163/holy-bagumba-kate-dicamillo-s-flora-ulysses-takes-readers-on-an-incandescent-adventure-costco-connection http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/426/insights-on-business-from-the-rosetta-stone http://www.theessentialhrhandbook.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/1058/michael-gerber-takes-us-inside-the-dreaming-room http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1462/government+rules http://trulyamazingwomen.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/2100/Montpelier http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1897/mob-rules-what-former-heist-expert-louis-ferrante-can-teach-you http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/102/the-bognet-way http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/2055/the-fun-of-paying-it-forward http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1272/Seth+Goldman www.houseofsteep.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1918/dr-andrew-weil-s-tips-for-achieving-emotional-well-being http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/2100/Montpelier http://inkandescentnetworking.com/?s=network http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/2229/science-of-gratitude http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/650/guy-kawasaki-s-enchantment-the-art-of-changing-hearts-minds-and-actions http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/1966/selling-with-noble-purpose-what-you-need-to-know http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/1163/what-it-means-to-have-it-all-insights-from-52-truly-amazing-women-and-some-amazing-men http://www.weaversway.coop http://www.inkandescentpr.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/714/wannabe-fools http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1202/3-ways-to-become-more-empathetic http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/359/steven-schussler-s-5-ps-for-business-success-personality-product-persistence-people-philanthropy http://www.inkandescentnetworking.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/781/alan-webber-s-favorite-rules-for-2012-and-beyond http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/2230/what-can-entrepreneurs-do-to-fight-for-human-rights-karen-hanrahan-explains http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/2147/andy-hines-shines-a-light-on-the-future-of-the-workforce http://inkandescentnetworking.com/index.php?s=host-directory http://www.pr-rules.com http://inkandescentnewsletters.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/954/martha-beck-helps-you-find-your-way-in-a-wild-new-world http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/620/unleash-your-potential http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/561/starbucks-rules http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/893/Maria+Bartiromo http://www.theinkandescentradioshow.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/270/jonathan-alter-s-tips-for-entrepreneurs www.bartlettpearinn.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1870/dr+ruta+aidis http://www.weaversway.coop http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/818/reebok-s-president-uli-becker-jumpstarts-the-shaping-up-of-america http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1737/Zieglers+7+Tips http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/21/julie-s-tips-for-entrepreneurs http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/299/dr-ben-carson-offers-advice-for-entrepreneurs-on-how-to-conduct-a-best-worst-analysis http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/447/a-look-inside-the-nature-conservancy http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1819/mansour-javidan-s-tips-for-successful-global-leaders http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1763/how-to-create-a-lean-in-circle http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/205/muhammad-yunus-tips-for-entrepreneurs http://beinkandescent.com/back-issues?q=2011-10 http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/2082/what-will-your-second-act-be http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/152/tactical-tips-from-gina-schaefer http://www.currysauto.com http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/863/ridley-pearson-lights-up-the-sky http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/501/lee+woodruff+tips http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/650/guy-kawasaki-s-enchantment-the-art-of-changing-hearts-minds-and-actions http://www.inkandescentspeakers.com http://www.beinkandescent. com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/586/ I%27ll+Mature+When+I%27m+Dead http://inkandescentpr.com http://www.andyhinesight.com/ http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1791/7+Top+Dog+Tips http://artatlargeinc.com/ http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/1127/entrepreneurs-in-education http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/653/guy-kawasaki-s-journey-to-enchantment http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/530/to-everything-turn-turn-turn-roger-and-camilla-mcguinn-s-tips-for-entrepreneurs http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/1288/do-you-have-the-barefoot-spirit-here-s-are-11-ways-to-harness-it http://www.beinkandescent.com/tips-for-entrepreneurs/653/guy-kawasaki-s-journey-to-enchantment http://www.beinkandescent.com/entrepreneur-of-the-month/1987/darrah-cloud